Listen To The Article
I want to tell you the fascinating story about the history of vinegar-based fruit juices. It seems like food and drink trends always bring us back to the phrase… “everything old is new again.” Beekeeping, backyard chickens, whole foods, and local foods have become downright fashionable, and for good reason.
Of course, those who are homesteaders and “do-it-yourselfers” know that many of the old ways are the best ways.
Vinegar-based fruit juices are no exception. Today, you’ll find some of these refreshing drinks referenced in gourmet magazines and food websites. Moreover, they were alluded to in the Bible and have roots  in many places around the world. Interestingly, these drinks were also very commonly found in American homes during the colonial times. They were also a common method of preserving foods prior to refrigeration, thereby making them a typical and popular choice of drink in early America.
Switchels, as people call them, are vinegar-based fruit juices. Very simply, they consist of a mixture of fruit, vinegar, and sugar that is consumed both alone and is sometimes used as a base for a cocktail. From China to England, they have an amazing history in many cultures spanning the globe.
Switchels, which are sometimes called “shrubs,” truly came into their own in America with the early colonists. Moreover, there are some very interesting places where switchels show up in American history. A recipe for switchels is chronicled in Founding Father Benjamin Franklin’s papers according to the American Philosophical Society. Later, during the War of 1812, Captain James Dacres, an English Naval captain, battled the American ship USS Constitution. Historians discovered that as the battle raged on, Captain Dacres fantasized about serving Americans this drink when they surrendered. Like a Coke or a Pepsi today, switchels were seen as the epitome of American drinks. Captain Dacres apparently dreamed about rubbing the Americans’ noses in their favorite drink so to speak, as they lost the battle to Britain. However, as history played out, the American Navy sank his ship and he received his own “drink” of a different sort.
Switchels also played a role in the American temperance movement, as they were lauded (at least the non-alcoholic version) as a refreshing alternative to an alcoholic drink.
It was also during this time period that switchel drinking began to be seen in association with many medical benefits. Today, we again recognize the benefits of vinegar, particularly apple cider vinegar , for a variety of ailments. (Historically, sailors used it to prevent sickness at sea.)
Of course, they would not have been consumed had Americans and folks around the world not preserved fruit this way first as a means of storage. This was perhaps the primary function of switchels prior to refrigeration. Furthermore, the “Canning Across America ” website offers a great recipe for canning strawberry switchels.
Vinegar-Based Fruit Juices: Pickled Strawberries
Adapted from The Complete Book of Pickling, by Jennifer MacKenzie
- 6 pints strawberries, hulled (preferably on the smaller side and just a touch under-ripe)
- 3 cups granulated sugar
- 1 teaspoon kosher salt or 3/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
- 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
- 1/4 teaspoon ground cloves
- 1/8 teaspoon ground allspice
- 2 cups cider vinegar
-First of all, puncture strawberries with fork tines and cut any large ones in half.
-Combine remaining ingredients together in a large saucepan. Bring to a boil, stirring until sugar and salt are dissolved. Remove from heat and let cool slightly. Pour over prepared berries.
-Cover the berries and let stand at a cool room temperature for at least six hours or overnight. In addition, prepare water bath canner, jars, and lids.
-Re-heat berries, gently stirring occasionally until strawberries are heated through but still hold their shape.
-Gently spoon strawberries and hot pickling liquid into hot jars, leaving ½ inch head space. Remove air bubbles and adjust head space as necessary. Wipe rim and place hot lid on jar, screwing band down until fingertip-tight.
-Place jars in canner and return to a boil. Process for 10 minutes.
-Turn off heat, remove canner lid, and let jars stand in hot water for an additional 5 minutes.
-Transfer jars to a towel-lined surface or a cooling rack and let them stand undisturbed until completely cool, which will be in about 24 hours. Finally, check lids and refrigerate any jars that are not sealed.
Makes approximately 6 pints.
Vinegar-Based Fruit Juices: The Strawberry Switchel
- 2-3 tablespoons pickled strawberry syrup (and whole fruit if you like)
- 12 ounces sparkling water or club soda
Stir together in a tall glass, with or without ice, and enjoy. Add more syrup to taste.
You do not have to can switchels. You can make them for immediate consumption and refrigerate them. In addition, the Ultimate History Project  website offers a great recipe for non-canned switchels.
Vinegar-Based Fruit Juices: The Pomegranate Switchel
- 3-4 large pomegranates
- 1 3/4 cups of sugar
- 1 cup cider vinegar
1. Line a colander with cheesecloth and place it over a clean glass (or other non-reactive) bowl. Roll the pomegranates on the counter to loosen the seeds, then cut them into quarters. Invert the quarters and pop the seeds out into the colander.
2. Pick out any of the white pith that fell into the seeds, as it will lend a bitter note to the finished product if you don’t. Pull the ends of the cheesecloth and squeeze the pomegranate seeds as hard as you can. Keep squeezing and twisting until you have only the inner kernels left in the cloth. Throw that away. As a result, you should have about two cups of liquid.
3. Mix the liquid with the sugar (use more if you like it sweeter). Stir to try to dissolve as much of the sugar as possible.
4. Add the vinegar to the mixture, pour the whole thing into a clean bottle, cap it securely, and shake it. Place it in the refrigerator and let it sit for 2 weeks. Shake it whenever you think of it.
5. Finally, uncork it and give it a sniff. It will smell very vinegary. Mix a small amount with seltzer water and taste it. It will seem extremely sour to the modern palate, but mixed with seltzer or vodka in the right proportions, it is indeed, very refreshing. If you find it too sour, simply add more sugar and let it sit for another day.
Notes On Vinegar-Based Fruit Juices
To make this recipe with any other fruit, just chop up the fruit very coarsely. Next, mix it with the sugar and let the mixture sit on the counter or in the fridge for several hours until the juice oozes out of the fruit. (Blemished fruit is great for this!). Then, strain the fruit through a sieve and mix the resulting sugary juice with the vinegar. Some people cook the fruit for a time with the sugar to produce the syrup. Both methods work perfectly well.
Like other canned and preserved foods, you will also possess a deeper appreciation for a drink that you preserved with your own hands. How delicious and refreshing a vinegar-based, berry-flavored, and preserved drink is, especially when watching the snow fly!
So, whether you consume it as a fruit drink or as a base for a cocktail, it’s a wonderful “glass of history” to enjoy on a hot summer day as well.
Have you ever made vinegar-based fruit juices? What tips would you suggest? Share your thoughts in the comments below.
“Cooling Off With Switchels and Shrubs. “The Ultimate History Project.” UHP, nd. Web. 4, Nov.2015
Cotner, Meg “How To Make A Shrub Syrup.” “Harmonious Belly.” Self published 19, July, 2012.Web. 4, Nov.2015.
“Difford’s Guide For Discerning Drinkers.” “Class Magazine.” “Odd Firm of Sin Ltd.” 9, Aug.2011.Web. 4, Nov.2015.
Jung, Alyssa (Adapted). “Thirteen Health Benefits of Apple Cider Vinegar.” Reader’s Digest.”Life Rich Publishing.N.D. Web.4, Nov.2015.
Kim. “Strawberries +Vinegar=Shrub, A Beverage Revelation.” Canning Across America.” N.P.16, July, 2012. Web. 4, Nov.2015.