• Home
  • About Off The Grid
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Tuesday, May 13, 2025
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
No Result
View All Result
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
No Result
View All Result
Off The Grid News
Home Current Events

Why The Newest Supreme Court Ruling Could Make You Scared To Drive

by Off The Grid News Staff
in Current Events
Print Print
highway patrol supreme court anonymous tip

Image source: NapleNews.com

Share on FacebookShare on XShare on TruthEmail Article
highway patrol supreme court anonymous tip
Image source: NapleNews.com

The Supreme Court has ruled that police only need an anonymous tip – and no other evidence — to pull a vehicle over and search it, the United States Supreme Court has ruled.

The ruling in a case called Prado Navarette et al vs. California drastically expands law enforcement’s ability to stop vehicles.

The case was brought by a man named Lorenzo Prado Navarette, who was pulled over because his truck matched a description from an anonymous 911 caller who said the driver was drunk. Navarette, though, had not been drinking and his driving was not erratic

During the stop the California Highway Patrol found 30 pounds of marijuana in Navarette’s truck and arrested him.

The ruling divided the Supreme Court’s conservative bloc, with Justice Antonin Scalia – a leading conservative – writing the dissent. He wrote a scathing dissent and said the ruling sets a precedent that could be a major threat to individual freedoms.

‘Freedom-Destroying Cocktail’

“The Court’s opinion serves up a freedom-destroying cocktail consisting of two parts patent falsity: (1) that anonymous 911 reports of traffic violations are reliable so long as they correctly identify a car and its location, and (2) that a single instance of careless or reckless driving necessarily supports a reasonable suspicion of drunkenness,” Scalia wrote.

Discover The Only Way Back To True Freedom And Liberty In America…

“All the malevolent 911 caller need do is assert a traffic violation, and the targeted car will be stopped, forcibly if necessary, by the police,” Scalia charged. “If the driver turns out not to be drunk (which will almost always be the case), the caller need fear no consequences, even if 911 knows his identity. After all, he never alleged drunkenness, but merely called in a traffic violation—and on that point his word is as good as his victim’s.”

Scalia alleges that a person who had a grudge, for instance, could call 911 and falsely charge drunken driving in order to get that person pulled over. To make matters worse, police could pull any vehicle over that matches the description. This could make it easier than ever for law enforcement to stop vehicles and confiscate cash or guns.

Searches Based On Anonymous Tips Constitutional

Five Supreme Court justices believe that the highway patrol’s actions did not violate the Fourth Amendment’s prohibition on unreasonable searches and seizures. In the majority opinion, Justice Clarence Thomas wrote that the Fourth Amendment allows what he calls “brief investigative stops” of vehicles.

“The traffic stop complied with the Fourth Amendment because, under the totality of the circumstances, the officer had reasonable suspicion that the truck’s driver was intoxicated,” Thomas wrote. Navarette’s attorneys argued that the stop violated the Fourth Amendment because it was based on an anonymous tip.

Thomas noted that the 911 call that led to the arrests of Navarette and another man came from a woman who claimed to have been run off the road by a drunk driver. Thomas also wrote that police have the right to pull vehicles over and search them when they have reasonable suspicion of criminal activity.

Freedom of Movement Threatened?

The Navarette decision gives police a blank check to stop any vehicle anytime as long as they have an anonymous tip, Scalia charged. He also alleged that it could threaten Americans’ freedom of movement.

“After today’s opinion all of us on the road, and not just drug dealers, are at risk of having our freedom of movement curtailed on suspicion of drunkenness, based upon a phone tip, true or false, of a single instance of careless driving,” Scalia concluded.

Some of the recent incidents of police stops and searches of vehicles reported by Off the Grid News indicate that Scalia’s concerns are valid. Drivers around the United States have reported having vehicles searched on questionable grounds and having cash, guns and other assets seized by officers without warrants.

Justices Ruth Bader Ginsburg, Sonia Sotomayor and Elena Kagan joined Scalia in his dissent. Chief Justice John Roberts and Justices Anthony Kennedy, Stephen Breyer and Samuel Alito joined the majority opinion written by Thomas.

What do you think about the Supreme Court’s ruling? Let us know in the comments below.

Sign up for Off The Grid News’ weekly email and stay informed about the issues important to you

ShareTweetShareSend

Related Posts

Doomsday Dominoes: What Happens When Nukes Are Launched In India Or Pakistan

Doomsday Dominoes: What Happens When Nukes Are Launched In India Or Pakistan

by Bill Heid

Health, Environmental, and Economic Impacts of a Nuclear War Between India and Pakistan The specter of nuclear conflict remains one...

The Long…  Bloody History of India and Pakistan’s Endless Conflict

The Long… Bloody History of India and Pakistan’s Endless Conflict

by Bill Heid

A Nation Born in Bloodshed The roots of the ongoing hostility between India and Pakistan officially stretch back to 1947,...

Urgent: The Top 25 Drugs and Made-In-China Medicines Set To Explode In Price Or Disappear Completely

Urgent: The Top 25 Drugs and Made-In-China Medicines Set To Explode In Price Or Disappear Completely

by Bill Heid

How Tariffs on China-Made Drugs Could Hit Your Medicine Cabinet and Wallet Most Americans are unaware that a staggering percentage...

Next Post
off grid stove

The 7 Greatest Off-Grid Stoves For Survival Cooking

Please login to join discussion

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

Infected Food: Is This Toxic Virus On Your Plate?

Infected Food: Is This Toxic Virus On Your Plate?

Will Unrest in Syria Really Impact America?

Will Unrest in Syria Really Impact America?

How to Make a Homemade Distillery

How to Make a Homemade Distillery

TRENDING STORIES

  • bubonic plague

    Is Another Bubonic Plague Pandemic On The Horizon?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Waco Fertilizer Plant Explosion & A Look Back On The “Waco Massacre”

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Make Yourself 3 Times More Likely To Survive A Heart Attack

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • AI Surveillance Of Shoppers: Walmart’s Newest Tool To Grab Your Data

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘Apocalyptic’ Microchip Implants Are Here – And Being Inserted Into People’s Hands

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Subscribe to our Insider Newsletter

Huge discounts on off-the-grid gear and life saving supplements.






‘Off The Grid News’ is an independent, weekly email newsletter and website that is crammed full of practical information on living and surviving off the grid. Advice you’ll never hear from the mainstream media.

  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Extreme Survival
  • Survival Gardening
  • Off-Grid Foods
  • Worldview
  • Natural Health
  • Survival Hunting
  • Privacy
  • Financial
  • Current Events
  • Self Defense
  • Home Defense
  • Pain-Free Living
  • Miscellaneous
  • Off Grid Videos

© Copyright 2025 Off The Grid News.  All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
  • Videos

© Copyright 2025 Off The Grid News.  All Rights Reserved.