• Home
  • About Off The Grid
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
Friday, June 13, 2025
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
No Result
View All Result
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
No Result
View All Result
Off The Grid News
Home Privacy

Obama Administration Gets Its Way As Supreme Court Declines NSA Review

by Tara Dodrill
in Privacy
Print Print
Supreme Court
Share on FacebookShare on XShare on TruthEmail Article

Supreme CourtThe Obama administration didn’t want the US Supreme Court to rule on the legality of the federal government’s collection of large numbers of telephone records, and it got its ways Monday when the Supreme Court declined to hear a case pertaining to the National Security Agency’s surveillance efforts.

The collection of so-called metadata or information about communications is at the heart of the NSA’s surveillance.

Without comment, the justices chose not to take the case  — at least not yet — and opted to allow it to work its way through the lower courts.

The US Solicitor General had filed a brief asking the Supreme Court to reject the petition that would required the high court to review a court order that required Verizon to supply metadata about telephone calls to the FBI and the NSA. The court order was issued in April 2013 by Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court (FISA) Judge Robert Vinson.

Vinson exceeded his authority and violated the privacy rights of Verizon customers by issuing the order, attorneys for the Electronic Privacy Information Center (EPIC) contend. In a response, the Solicitor General claimed that that EPIC petition does not meet the legal requirements for a mandamus petition.

Revisit the counsel of great men and learn how to reclaim the quality of government we once enjoyed.

A mandamus petition is a writ or order in which a higher court commands a lower court to take a specific action. EPIC wants the Supreme Court to order FISA to stop granting so-called production orders that require telecoms such as Verizon to turn metadata over to the NSA and other agencies.

An extraordinary remedy

EPIC was asking “for an extraordinary remedy,” Harvard Law school student Laruen Bateman noted at the Lawfare Blog. “Petitioners must first prove that this is the type of case for which the court would consider granting mandamus relief, then prove that they would likely win on the merits.”

The Solicitor General contended that EPIC’s petition did not meet either of those requirements. EPIC’s attorneys disagreed, saying the requested remedy was necessary.

“Mandamus relief is warranted because the [FISA court] exceeded its statutory jurisdiction when it ordered production of millions of domestic telephone records that cannot plausibly relevant to an investigation,” EPIC said.

Like US Rep. Jim Sensenbrenner (R-Wisconsin) EPIC’s attorneys contend that the NSA and FISA court are violating the Patriot Act by issuing such orders. Sensenbrenner wrote the original Patriot Act and has claimed that the metadata programs violate it. As previously reported by Off The Grid News, he has written a proposed law called the USA Freedom Act that would ban the collection of telephony metadata.

Telephone Metadata Allows Government to Track You

“Telephone metadata includes comprehensive routing information,” EPIC noted in its brief. Such information includes:

  • Telephone call card numbers.
  • Telephone numbers.
  • International mobile subscriber identity numbers.
  • Trunk identifier.
  • International mobile station equipment identity number.
  • Time of call.
  • Duration of call.

This information can be used to identify and trace people making telephone calls, EPIC says. In June Edward Snowden leaked documents to various newspapers that showed the NSA has a massive program for the collection of such data. EPIC’s petition for mandamus was prompted by Snowden’s leaks.

The Solicitor General claimed that data from every phone call made in the United States in the past five years is relevant to the investigation terrorism, Politico’s Josh Gerstein noted.

One of several legal challenges to surveillance

EPIC’s petition is one of several challenges to surveillance programs making their way through the courts. The petition is the most direct because it demands immediate action from the Supreme Court and asks the court to take specific action to halt some of the efforts.

Other legal actions seeking the courts to stop surveillance include:

  • A lawsuit filed by the American Civil Liberties Union in June in federal court in Manhattan.
  • A lawsuit filed by the Electronic Frontier Foundation in July in San Francisco.
  • A suit filed by conservative activist Larry Klayman in Washington in June.

ShareTweetShareSend

Related Posts

Neuralink’s Dangerous New Trademark Filings

Neuralink’s Dangerous New Trademark Filings

by Bill Heid

The Dark Side of Neural Implants… Power… Privacy… and Control? From an observer’s standpoint, Neuralink’s newly filed trademarks signal an...

When Powerful Machines Are Watching: Privacy Threats and Your Best Defenses in an Automated World

When Powerful Machines Are Watching: Privacy Threats and Your Best Defenses in an Automated World

by Bill Heid

Between Innovation and Intrusion: Safeguarding Privacy in the Age of AI Artificial intelligence is evolving at a breathtaking pace, revolutionizing...

Unraveling the Chemical Complexity of Pine Needles

Safeguarding Your Children’s Privacy in a “Connected” Christmas

by Bill Heid

Are your child’s experiences being sent to massive data centers? Increasingly, these special surprises include advanced technology… toys that respond...

Next Post

Amazing Stories About Our Pilgrim Forefathers You’ve Never Heard, Episode 184 (interview with Sue Allan)

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE

The Clear And Present Dangers Of A Power Grid Collapse

The Clear And Present Dangers Of A Power Grid Collapse

The Ancient Roots of Pine Needle Remedies

The Ancient Roots of Pine Needle Remedies

7 Remarkable ‘Outside-The-Kitchen’ Uses For Honey

7 Remarkable ‘Outside-The-Kitchen’ Uses For Honey

TRENDING STORIES

  • bubonic plague

    Is Another Bubonic Plague Pandemic On The Horizon?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Waco Fertilizer Plant Explosion & A Look Back On The “Waco Massacre”

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Make Yourself 3 Times More Likely To Survive A Heart Attack

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • AI Surveillance Of Shoppers: Walmart’s Newest Tool To Grab Your Data

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • ‘Apocalyptic’ Microchip Implants Are Here – And Being Inserted Into People’s Hands

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0

Subscribe to our Insider Newsletter

Huge discounts on off-the-grid gear and life saving supplements.






‘Off The Grid News’ is an independent, weekly email newsletter and website that is crammed full of practical information on living and surviving off the grid. Advice you’ll never hear from the mainstream media.

  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Extreme Survival
  • Survival Gardening
  • Off-Grid Foods
  • Worldview
  • Natural Health
  • Survival Hunting
  • Privacy
  • Financial
  • Current Events
  • Self Defense
  • Home Defense
  • Pain-Free Living
  • Miscellaneous
  • Off Grid Videos

© Copyright 2025 Off The Grid News.  All Rights Reserved.

Privacy Policy   Terms & Conditions
No Result
View All Result
  • How-To
  • Grid Threats
  • Survival
  • Gardening
  • Food
  • Worldview
  • Health
  • Privacy
  • Hunting
  • Defense
  • Financial
  • News
  • Misc
  • Videos

© Copyright 2025 Off The Grid News.  All Rights Reserved.